WYAL-FM 103.3

The Curse of the Pharaohs: What Really Happened After Tutankhamun's Tomb Was Opened

On November 26, 1922, Howard Carter made a small hole in the sealed doorway of a previously undisturbed tomb in the Valley of the Kings and held a candle to the gap. Lord Carnarvon, peering over his shoulder, asked if he could see anything. Carter's reply has become one of the most famous sentences in the history of archaeology: "Yes. Wonderful things." Within six months, Lord Carnarvon was dead. Within a decade, several more members of the expedition team had died in circumstances ranging from ordinary to spectacular. The press had a narrative. Whether the narrative was accurate is a different question.

The Deaths: What Actually Happened and What the Statistics Show

The "Curse of the Pharaohs" narrative is built on a selective reading of the deaths that followed the opening of Tutankhamun's tomb. The narrative was constructed largely by the press, particularly E.A. Wallis Budge at the British Museum and reporters at the Daily Mail, who found a compelling story in Carnarvon's death and constructed a pattern around it. Examining the actual deaths with statistical rigor produces a different picture.

Lord Carnarvon died on April 5, 1923, in Cairo. He had been suffering from ill health for years following a serious automobile accident in 1901 that had permanently compromised his lung function. In Egypt, he received a mosquito bite that became infected; the infection spread systemically to his compromised respiratory system. He died of blood poisoning and pneumonia. He was 57. His death was medically unremarkable for a 57-year-old man with pre-existing severe lung disease who received a significant bacterial infection in a pre-antibiotic era.

Georges Benedite, a curator at the Louvre, visited the tomb and died three months later, at age 69, of a stroke. Arthur Mace, an archaeologist who worked to unwrap the mummy, died of arsenic poisoning in 1928. Mace had been suffering health problems for years before entering the tomb; whether the arsenic exposure was occupational, environmental, or curse-related remains unresolved. Hugh Evelyn-White, a linguist who worked at the tomb site, died by suicide in 1924, leaving a note (reportedly, though the text is disputed) that referenced the pharaoh's ghost.

The 2002 statistical analysis by epidemiologist Mark Nelson, published in the British Medical Journal, examined the actuarial data. Nelson identified everyone who was documented as being present at significant events related to the tomb opening -- the opening of the burial chamber, the opening of the sarcophagus, the unwrapping of the mummy -- and analyzed their survival rates against actuarial tables for people of their age and national origin in the relevant period. His conclusion: no statistically significant difference in mortality between those exposed and those not. The "curse" death rate, when analyzed against the baseline death rate for people in this demographic, was within normal parameters. The narrative was constructed by selecting the dramatic deaths and not counting the many expedition members who lived to advanced ages.

The Curse Inscription: A Journalistic Fabrication

The inscription most associated with the Tutankhamun curse -- "Let death come on swift wings to he who disturbs the peace of the King" -- does not appear in the excavation records. Howard Carter, who was meticulous in documenting every artifact, inscription, and architectural feature of the tomb, never recorded any such text. Arthur Weigall, an Egyptologist who was present at the opening, specifically stated that no curse inscription was found in the tomb.

The probable origin of the "curse inscription" is a journalist's invention that then circulated without the journalistic scrutiny that might have caught it. This is not unusual in early 20th-century newspaper practice: dramatic details that enhanced a good story were regularly added without verification. The Carnarvon death gave the story a real death to work with, and the invented inscription gave the story a mechanism. The combination was irresistible and the fiction became historical fact in most popular accounts.

Note, importantly, that genuine warning inscriptions do exist in Egyptian tombs. The pyramid of Amenemhat I (12th dynasty) contains a text that reads: "All people who enter this tomb who will make evil against this tomb and destroy it: may the crocodile be against them on water, and snakes against them on land. May the hippopotamus be against them on water, the scorpion and snake be against them on land, to him who shall destroy this." This is a genuine curse inscription. It is not from Tutankhamun's tomb. The conflation of real curse inscriptions from other tombs with the Tutankhamun narrative is part of how the myth gained textual credibility.

The Scientific Lens: Fungal Pathogens and the Biological Curse

The most scientifically serious explanation for the tomb deaths -- and for the broader phenomenon of illness following entry into sealed ancient tombs -- is microbial contamination. Dr. Ezzeddin Taha, an Egyptian microbiologist, published research in 1962 documenting that workers at Egyptian museums and excavation sites showed significantly elevated exposure to Aspergillus fungi compared to control populations. Aspergillus niger and Aspergillus flavus are both potentially dangerous to immunocompromised individuals; in healthy immune systems they are typically harmless or cause minor respiratory irritation, but in individuals with pre-existing lung disease or immune compromise they can cause serious infections.

Sealed tombs are potential preservatories for biological agents. Several factors contribute: ancient Egyptians used organic materials in the mummification and burial process that could support microbial growth; bat colonies frequently occupied tombs over the millennia (bat guano bacteria including Histoplasma capsulatum can cause serious respiratory disease); and the sealed environment prevented dispersal of airborne particles that formed when the tombs were disturbed. The first breaths taken in a newly opened sealed space would expose individuals to a concentrated bolus of whatever had been accumulating for millennia.

Troublingly for this hypothesis: neither Carnarvon nor some other notable deaths appear to have significant immunocompromise. Carnarvon's lung damage created vulnerability, which supports the hypothesis for his case specifically. The broader statistical null result from the Nelson analysis suggests that even if some deaths were pathogen-related, the overall mortality pattern was not elevated. The pathogen hypothesis explains some individual cases plausibly without constituting a generalizable "curse."

Historical Deep Dive: What Egypt Actually Thought About Tomb Violation

Ancient Egyptian religious architecture was not naive about the possibility of tomb violation. The elaborate mechanical precautions -- concealed chambers, false passages, blocking stones -- reflect a realistic expectation that some tombs would be robbed and a corresponding investment in making robbing difficult. Only Tutankhamun's tomb in the Valley of the Kings survived substantially intact to modern excavation; all others had been robbed in antiquity, some within decades of their sealing.

The occupational practices of ancient Egyptian tomb builders and embalmers included specific protections that can be read either as ritual curse-avoidance or as what we would now call occupational safety measures. Workers in royal tombs were required to undergo ritual purification before entry, to cover their faces with linen when working near the mummy or with certain substances, and to follow specific procedures when handling embalming materials. The substances used in Egyptian embalming included natron (naturally occurring sodium salt), various plant resins including frankincense and myrrh, and bitumen (in some periods). Several of these substances have documented biocidal or toxic properties at high concentrations.

The workers who built the Valley of the Kings tombs lived in a dedicated village at Deir el-Medina, which has been extensively excavated. Their letters and legal records (preserved on ostraca -- writing on pottery shards) reveal a workforce that was well-paid by ancient standards, was organized in a proto-union structure with the ability to strike (and did so, conducting what may be the first recorded labor strike in history around 1170 BCE), and maintained detailed records of working conditions. Their medical records show no unusual pattern of illness consistent with systematic curse deaths. They worked in the tombs regularly and lived long lives by ancient standards.

The Skeptic's Corner: Survivor Bias, Selection, and the Missing Survivors

The curse narrative's most significant methodological problem is selection bias: the deaths are memorable and counted; the survivals are not. Howard Carter himself, who spent more time in the tomb than any other expedition member, lived to age 64 and died in 1939, seventeen years after the tomb's opening. Harry Burton, the expedition photographer who spent months documenting every corner of the tomb, lived to 1940. Alan Gardiner, who translated the hieroglyphics, lived to 84. Percy Newberry lived to 78. Fourteen of the twenty-six people documented as present at the tomb opening in 1922 lived past 1934, more than twelve years later. The average age at death of the documented expedition members was 73.

This is the data that the curse narrative does not report. A group of men in their 50s to 70s, working in a challenging environment and in an era before modern medicine, will lose members to ordinary mortality over a decade. Some of those deaths will be dramatic. In a group with a compelling mythology already attached, the dramatic deaths will be selected for memory and the quiet deaths at old age will be forgotten. The "curse" is partially a function of how human narrative memory works: we remember the exceptions and forget the rule.

Transmission Intercepts: Witness Accounts

"My grandmother worked for an antiquities dealer in Cairo in the 1950s. She would handle objects from the tombs regularly. She always washed her hands and face immediately after and changed her clothes. She said 'this is what you do with old things.' She lived to 91. She never thought there was a curse. She thought there was dust."

-- Listener submission, received January 2026

"I visited the Cairo Museum and saw Tutankhamun's artifacts in 2018. The gold face was in a case under lights and I stood there for ten minutes trying to understand what I was looking at. A boy, three thousand years ago, buried with everything they could fit in four rooms. What's haunted about that isn't a curse. It's just the weight of the time."

-- Listener submission, received February 2026